Introduction


The Exit Cafe is dedicated to helping investors and professionals of all experience levels be more aware of changes to their risk exposure and the importance of using an intelligent exit strategy to control and act upon risk.

The editorial manager and a frequent contributor to our blog is Chuck LeBeau, an industry leader in the application of technical analysis for risk management. We hope you find our blog enjoyable, educational and valuable. Please feel free to chime in on any stories or analysis posted.

Feb 26, 2009

Quote of the day

“The highest form of ignorance is when you reject something you don't know anything about.”

Wayne Dyer (b1940)

Feb 25, 2009

Trading Messages From Mars

Chuck LeBeau Wisdom

"This excerpt is from Chuck LeBeau. Chuck happens to be one of the pioneers in the field of trading systems. His wisdom should be absorbed by all"
Michael Covel

Michael Covel is the Author of The Complete TurtleTrader & the bestseller Trend Following
Covel Is also the Director of the New Documentary Film Broke: The New American Dream


"[This] happens to be a true story, which contains a very valuable trading lesson that has influenced my trading for many years now. We thought the story might make an interesting topic...Here is the story: Back in the late 1960s I was a young commodity broker at E. F. Hutton and Company. Our office was a brand new high-tech office (for its time) which was considered the "flagship office" for E. F. Hutton. In this office about thirty brokers and as many clients shared one very large boardroom and there were no private offices. The brokers had elegant and expensive desks and the clients had a comfortable seating area in the front of the office where they could hang out and watch the tapes and monitor our state of the art commodity "clacker board". Sitting at my desk near the front of the boardroom I could read my Wall Street Journal and keep track of the commodity markets without looking at the board. By just listening to the rhythm and tempo of the mechanical clicks as the prices changed I could easily tell when anything important was going on because the tempo of the clicks would increase noticeably. Just in front of my desk were a half dozen comfortable sofas facing a high mahogany paneled wall with the tapes and the "clacker board". A gallery of traders, mostly retired "old timers" who were trading real commodities like grains and pork bellies, lounged around on the sofas plotting their charts and talking about life and the markets. They typically arrived early to get a good seat in their usual spot and then spent the day trading, exchanging commentaries and offering unsolicited advice to one another on any subject. For the most part they were a very sociable group who would take coffee breaks together and greeted each other on a first name basis. These traders enjoyed the elegant atmosphere and treated our well-appointed boardroom as their private men's club. (Were you aware that women were not allowed to trade commodities back in those days? My how times have changed!) However, one of these "old timers" kept to himself and was not interested in becoming a member of the friendly and often boisterous social circle. He usually sat quietly by himself intently watching the price changes on the commodity board and holding an old glass Coca-Cola bottle up near his ear. The vintage shaped Coke bottle had been emptied many years before and now contained only a 12-inch tube of bent and broken radio antennae which extended awkwardly out of the top of the bottle. Keep in mind that in the 1960s no one had yet heard of cell phones so the purpose of this Coke bottle was a real mystery to everyone. When the trader would talk to the bottle from time to time all the heads would turn and the traders nearby would try to listen to the conversation. But the trader spoke very softly and no one was able to eavesdrop on his conversations with the bottle. The traders knew that the fellow with the coke bottle was a client of mine and eventually a representative of the group came to me and explained that they were extremely puzzled about this guy and his Coke bottle and asked me if I knew what was going on. I didn't know the purpose or meaning of the Coke bottle but I was as curious as anyone was and I promised I would find out. The next time the client came back to my desk I promptly placed his order and then politely asked him about the Coke bottle. With a serious expression and no embarrassment he explained to me that the Coke bottle was an inter-planetary communication device that had been given to him by aliens. He said that the aliens were very interested in our commodity markets and they often gave him trading advice from their various observation points on other planets. He said that he had just had a message from Mars and they were buying soybeans so he had also purchased soybeans. After revealing his unique trading methodology he returned to his seat and resumed his whispered conversations with the Coke bottle. As soon as I revealed my discovery of the meaning of the Coke bottle to the other traders, all attention was immediately focused on the Coke bottle trader and the soybean market. The soybean market proceeded to go the wrong way and the trade from Mars was eventually closed out at a loss. The other traders were had no sympathy and were quick to begin ridiculing the the trader and poke fun at his beliefs. The next trade however turned out to be a big winner and the Coke bottle trader went from sofa to sofa telling his story and pointing to the clacker board while waiving his Coke bottle and bragging about the profitability of his most recent message from outer space. Because he was making money now his previous critics had to endure his bragging about his success on the current winning trade. As time went on and a few winning and losing trades later a clear pattern of behavior began to emerge. The Coke bottle trader was ridiculed unmercifully on his losing trades but was able to get his revenge and the last laugh during the winning trades. This trader might have been a little bit crazy but he wasn't stupid. He soon learned that his only defense against ridicule was to hold on to winning trades as long as possible and to quickly get out of his losses. As long as he was sitting on his sofa with a winning trade no one could tell him he was crazy and make cruel jokes about his messages from Mars. In fact while he was winning he was quick to wander around the room and ridicule the methods of the other traders who were not making as much money as he was. He displayed the profits in his trading account as hard evidence of the validity of his methods and offered copies of his statements as irrefutable proof that he was getting valuable advice from his alien contacts. Who could argue when his advice from other planets was obviously working? As a young broker this experience and the first hand observation of the Coke bottle trader who suddenly became profitable gave me my first important lesson about the importance of exits. I knew the entry signals had nothing at all to do with his success. His batting average was not any better than that of any other trader. However, this crazy old trader seemed to be able to make money consistently while other traders with more "sanity" and more valid entry methods were losing. Before long I was able to recognize that this man had become a successful trader simply by his efforts to avoid ridicule. He knew that he was vulnerable during his losing trades so he closed them out very promptly. His winning trades became his shield against the ridicule of the other traders and he kept his winners much longer than before his unorthodox methods were revealed. In the many years since this experience I have encountered many claims of success for entry methods that probably have even less validity than the Coke bottle messages. I have learned to look only briefly at the entries of winning traders and to examine their exit strategies very carefully. I am very fortunate that more than thirty years ago I learned from the Coke bottle trader that success in trading depends on our exits and not our entries."

Chuck LeBeau

Feb 24, 2009

A great Article...

By John Waggoner, USA Today

One definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over, and expecting different results. If you have tried to snatch up a cheap stock in the past six months or so, you're probably questioning your sanity. Cheap stocks just keep getting cheaper.

For people who like bargains, stocks remain tempting. Many stocks are lower now than they were a decade ago. Before you decide to dive in again, however, make sure you have an exit strategy. You'll save yourself some money and, sooner or later, you might lose that twitch.

For many years, selling a stock was considered something that was Not Done, like bringing a clown to a funeral. After all, stocks always went up. Patience was the only answer to a stock tumble.

These days, however, those who hesitate are often lost. Say you bought 100 shares of Bank of America on Dec. 31 at $14.08. Price: $1,408.

You could have argued that Bank of America, the nation's third-largest bank holding company, was a cheap stock. It had already fallen 63% since Oct. 1. And it sold for 2.3 times its estimated 2010 earnings. (The price-earnings ratio, or P-E, measures how cheap a company's stock is relative to its earnings. The higher the P-E, the pricier the stock. Bank stocks typically sell for lower P-Es than most other stocks, but 2.3 is still inexpensive.)
Cheap or not, BAC wasn't a great buy. By Thursday, BAC closed at $3.93 a share, meaning you have lost $1,015, or 72%. In short, you've suffered a devastating loss: To get back even after losing 72%, you have to gain about 270%.

Ideally, you'd like to sell before taking such a huge loss. But how do you decide when to sell a stock?

Dan Chung, chief investment officer for the Alger funds, has a few general rules about selling. If the company produces a startling earnings disappointment, for example, you should consider selling, he says. You might also consider selling if you think another stock has better potential.

But you should also set a limit on how much you are prepared to lose the moment you buy a stock. One way to make sure you stick to that limit is to use a stop-loss order, which tells your broker to ditch the stock if it falls to a specific price.

You can put in a new stop-loss order every day, using a day order, or you can specify that your stop-loss will be good until you cancel it. (These orders don't last for all eternity; depending on your broker, they may last only six months or so.)

The next question: Where should you set your stop-loss order? In most cases, setting the stop at a 10% loss makes sense. You'll have to earn 11% to get back even, but an 11% loss is not a fatal error. Had you set a 10% stop on your Bank of America investment, for example, you'd be out about $141, plus commissions, rather than $1,015.

A stop-loss might not help in all circumstances. If your stock is down 10% when the Standard & Poor's 500 is down 15%, for example, it's holding up reasonably well. Some highly volatile (and low-priced) stocks will move up and down 10% pretty frequently. And, inevitably, you'll have some stocks that fall 10% and promptly rebound.

"Basically, we're talking about controlling risk," says Chuck LeBeau, director of analytics for SmartStops.net, a website that tells you when to sell. When you buy a stock, LeBeau says, you can't control how much it will go up. But you can limit your losses by using a stop-loss order.

SmartStops.net uses proprietary formulas, based on a stock's general direction and its volatility, to determine when to sell. The stop recommendations change every day. You can monitor a portfolio of three stocks or exchange traded funds for free, or get five stop recommendations a day for free.

If you're thinking of selling a mutual fund, which is typically a longer-term holding, then you need to examine the fund's record against other, similar funds over time. By and large, if a fund has lagged behind its peers for the past one, three and five years, it's time to ditch it. The chart shows five funds with assets of more than $1 billion that fit the sell criteria.

One place to get further guidance: The website FundAlarm, which is aimed at telling you when to send your fund to Palookaville.

Many investors have been burned enough by this market to sit on the sidelines for a while. If you're brave, or even mildly mad, be sure to have a sell point in mind the moment you buy.

John Waggoner is a personal finance columnist for USA TODAY. His Investing column appears Fridays. new book,Bailout: What the Rescue of Bear Stearns and the Credit Crisis Mean for Your Investments, is available through John Wiley & Sons. Click here for an index of Investing columns. His e-mail is jwaggoner@usatoday.com.

full link to the article
http://www.usatoday.com/money/perfi/columnist/waggon/2009-02-19-investing-stock-stop-loss_N.htm

Feb 17, 2009

So Much for Buy-and-Hold Advice

So Much for Buy-and-Hold Advice
You bet on stocks. You diversified. You lost a bundle. Should you get out? Experts disagree.

SmartStops comment:
In this day and age diversification offers very little protection and can even make things worse. You need protection on a stock by stock basis using SmartStops.

Excerpts: They were reassured that stocks have the best long-run returns, so they plowed their savings into the market—only to watch in dismay as government bonds outperformed stocks over an entire decade. Moreover, investors were lectured again and again on the wisdom of diversifying their portfolios internationally. So they did. But foreign markets have done even worse than their U.S. counterparts lately. The most exasperating example is Japan, whose key stock market index is now back to where it was in 1981.
What many investors have failed to realize is that "the long run" can sometimes be very, very long. So says London Business School economist Elroy Dimson, co-author with his LBS colleagues Paul Marsh and Mike Staunton of the 2002 book Triumph of the Optimists, which challenged work by University of Pennsylvania Wharton School professor Jeremy Siegel, author of Stocks for the Long Run. The climb back into the black after a fall can take even longer outside the U.S., says Dimson. In Italy, he says, stocks failed to keep up with inflation over a 73-year period through 1978.
But even in the absence of such a doomsday scenario, international diversification doesn't always lower the volatility of returns—because in major crises, stocks fall in every market. Thus, in 2008 global diversification isn't protecting investors from the financial crisis that originated in the U.S. In sum, two pillars of investment advice—buy stocks and go global—have proved to be weak reeds lately. No wonder pundits such as Jim Cramer, the CNBC stockpicker, are sounding off about "how the best way to invest is not to buy a bunch of stocks and just sit on them."

Link to full article:

Oct 18, 2008

Retirement accounts have lost $2 trillion

Retirement accounts have lost $2 trillion
By JULIE HIRSCHFELD DAVIS, AP

SmartStops comment: Elderly investors can no longer rely on Buy and Hold in today’s volatile markets. It may take too many years for the prices to recover. Investment portfolios need the protection that SmartStops can help to provide.

Excerpts: WASHINGTON -Americans' retirement plans have lost as much as $2 trillion in the past 15 months, Congress' top budget analyst estimated Tuesday.
The upheaval that has engulfed the financial industry and sent the stock market plummeting is devastating workers' savings, forcing people to hold off on major purchases and consider delaying their retirement, said Peter Orszag, the head of the Congressional Budget Office.

More than half the people surveyed in an Associated Press-GfK poll taken Sept. 27-30 said they worry they will have to work longer because the value of their retirement savings has declined.

A new AARP study found that because of the economic downturn, one in five workers 45 and older has stopped putting money into a 401(k), IRA or other retirement savings account during the past year, and nearly one in four has increased the number of hours he works.

Link to full article:

Oct 6, 2008

Dividend Cuts Hit $22.5 Billion in 3rd Quarter

Dividend Cuts Hit $22.5 Billion in 3rd Quarter
Standard & Poors press release

SmartStops comment: Investors in high dividend stocks often believe that they can ride the market up and down with little concern over declines in the stock prices .(As brokers used to joke in down markets- the yields are simply going up.) But what if the dividends that help protect the stock prices start getting cut? Based on the current news in this article, even dividend investors might benefit from the protection provided by SmartStops.

Excerpt from article: New York, October 3, 2008 - Standard & Poor’s, the world’s leading index provider, announced today that 138 of the approximately 7,000 publicly owned companies that report dividend information to Standard & Poor’s Dividend Record decreased their dividend during the third quarter of 2008, representing a 557% increase from the 21 issues that decreased their dividend during the third quarter of 2007. Reported dividend increases fell 21.2% to 346 from 439 reported in the third quarter of 2007.
“It was the worst September for dividends since we started keeping dividend records in 1956,” says Howard Silverblatt, Senior Index Analyst at Standard & Poor’s. “During the second quarter, companies were nervous and cautious. The third quarter, however, saw many companies deciding to take action, and that action took $22.5 billion out of the pockets of investors.”

Link to article:

Sep 7, 2008

Fannie, Freddie: The biggest losers

Fannie, Freddie: The biggest losers

Investors in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac face massive losses when trading opens Monday.
By Colin Barr, senior writer, Fortune

SmartStops comment: Only a few months ago these stocks were considered safe investments that were widely owned by banks and conservative institutions. Now FNM and FRE are close to worthless. (SmartStops would have had you out in the mid $20s on June 9th.) If you think that you own quality stocks that are so safe that you don’t need protection then you are clearly mistaken. Even the preferred shareholders are in trouble. Look at the list of supposedly knowledgeable investors and financial institutions that could have saved fortunes by simply using SmartStops.

Excerpts: NEW YORK (Fortune) -- Big investors in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac face a brutal Monday. Shares in the mortgage giants, which have already lost 90% of their value over the past year, are likely to plunge anew in the wake of the government's announcement Sunday that it is taking control of the companies and ending the payment of common and preferred dividends.
The prospect of a virtual wipeout of existing Fannie and Freddie preferred shares could lead to declines Monday in the shares of regional banks and major insurers that hold the shares. Among the holders of Fannie and Freddie preferred issues are Genworth Financial (GNW, Fortune 500) and MetLife (MET, Fortune 500).
The government intervention comes just over a month after Legg Mason's Miller reported a sizeable purchase of Freddie shares. Miller came to fame with a 15-year run of beating the S&P 500. But that streak ended in 2006, and since then his Legg Mason Value Trust has lagged far behind the market.
Miller's run of poor results hasn't made him any less aggressive, however. He has owned Freddie shares for some time but has been doubling down on the company as its shares plunged over the past year. Legg Mason owned 15 million shares at the end of 2007, when Freddie stock was fetching $34 a share in the market. He then boosted that figure to 50 million in the first quarter, as shares dropped into the teens in the wake of the collapse of Bear Stearns, and 80 million at July 31, when the price was below $10.
If the outlook for Freddie shares - which closed Friday at $5.10 but traded as low as $3.50 in the after-hours session when news of the Treasury plan began to circulate - is bleak, one ray of hope comes from the March collapse of Bear Stearns. Those shares were to be sold to J.P. Morgan Chase at $2 apiece in a Fed-brokered rescue of Bear, but the shares traded sharply above that level for a week, until the deal was renegotiated at $10.

Link to article:

WHEN TO SELL

When To Sell Stock: Here's The Best Tool For Knowing When To Unload Your Investment by Alexander Green, Chairman, Investment U.

SmartStops comment: Another excellent article from Alexander Green, the Oxford Club’s Chairman of “Investment U”. However we would disagree on a couple of points. The article suggests a 25% trailing stop but our SmartStops formulas have been proven to work much better.
(See our comparison study)

Also the article says: “Under no circumstances should you lower your stop.” As you have observed our stops are frequently moved further away as volatility increases so that they are not triggered by random price action. That is one of the important pieces of logic that makes our SmartStops so much more effective than a simple 25% trailing stop.

Excerpts: Anyone can buy a stock. The art of investing is knowing when to sell stock.
There are a number of theories about when to cash in your chips. But most of them are misguided. And some are completely wrongheaded.
For example, any analyst who urges you to sell a stock because the market is about to tank is immediately discredited, in my view. While there are certainly many bear markets and bull markets ahead of us, no one - and I mean that literally - has ever demonstrated any proficiency at warning investors in advance.
If there is truth to any of the great maxims of Wall Street it's this one: cut your losses and let your profits run. Selling a rising stock, by definition, is not letting your profits run.
There is, however, one sell discipline that forces you to do just that. It's called a trailing stop. And if you're not using one to protect your stock positions, you should be.
A trailing stop is simply a stop-loss order set a certain percentage below the market - and then adjusted as the price rises.
Traders, who are short-term oriented, will always want to run their sell stops closer than long-term investors. But even a short-term trader shouldn't run his stops too close to the market. Why? Because no stock moves up in a straight line. And you don't want to get knocked out of a winning stock while its just going through its normal fluctuations.
There is plenty of research to back up the idea of running trailing stops, incidentally.

Link to article: